I finished Conrad Black's Richard M. Nixon: A Life in Full. On page 1052, Black says the following about Henry Kissinger's eulogy to Richard Nixon at Nixon's 1994 funeral:
this critical moment, all rivalry between the two men finally vanished,
and Kissinger's own best instincts came naturally to his eulogist's
task. His voice broke slightly at one point, when he referred to
hearing 'the final news, by then so expected but so hard to accept,
[when] I felt a deep loss and a profound void.' (He told the author
that he felt that 'part of me died with him.')"
narrative about Richard Nixon's funeral: that it was an incident at
which Americans were brought together. Similarly, Daniel Frick states
on page 4 of his book, Reinventing Richard Nixon:
the Nixon funeral contained only...preaching to the converted, the
ceremony could only have been expected to exacerbate old divisions.
Whatever evocative power the funeral service might have had must have
come from its enactment of a ritual of political forgiveness between
longtime warring camps. Nixon himself could not have selected a more
perfect candidate to fulfill this task than Democratic president Bill
Clinton. First of all, as a Vietnam-era college student who had avoided
the draft and protested the war, he effectively symbolized the
irresponsibility and lack of patriotism that Nixon had claimed
epitomized too many in the baby boom generation. And, second, Watergate
had been pivotal in opening Clinton's political career...So, when in
his eulogy, President Clinton affirmed that Nixon had made mistakes and
that these were part of his record, no one could miss the unspoken
reference to Watergate. Only someone well-schooled in the catechism of
anti-Nixonism could credibly offer the absolution that followed: 'Today
is a day for his family, his friends and his nation to remember
President Nixon's life in totality. To them, let us say: may the day of
judging President Nixon on anything less than his entire life and
career come to a close...' As an attempt to face the past and move on,
this moment was the political high point of the ceremony: offering to
Nixon's memory a pardon more genuine and complete than the merely legal
one that Ford had granted."
Frick goes on to say that divisions
still remained, even during and after Nixon's funeral. But the
narrative that Nixon's funeral was a place that healed divisions stood
out to me on account of the opposite picture that I was reading in
Anthony Summers' anti-Nixon biography, The Arrogance of Power: The Secret World of Richard Nixon.
After Richard Nixon's death, Alger Hiss, the ex-State Department
official whom Nixon during the late 1940's said was a Communist spy,
said: "I am not going to gloat...There are a lot of things in that man's
life that were left unatoned for..." Summers probably agrees with
Hiss' assessment, since his book is about the negative things that Nixon
allegedly did throughout his political career.
Summers also notes who did not
attend Nixon's funeral. Some of them (i.e., Watergate conspirator E.
Howard Hunt) did not particularly surprise me. But some of what Summers
said on page xiv did stand out to me:
"Tens of thousands more
Vietnamese died in the short time that remained until South Vietnam
collapsed, less than a year after Nixon's resignation. The ousted
former president of South Vietnam, Nguyen Van Thieu, was not at the
"New research strengthens the suspicion that in 1968, on
the eve of the election that brought him to the White House, Nixon
manipulated the Vietnam War for selfish political ends. Did he, fearful
that impending peace negotiations would swing vital votes to his
Democratic opponent, covertly urge Thieu to boycott the talks? The
prominent Republican Anna Chennault, who met secretly with Nixon and
acted as a go-between with the South Vietnamese, claims he did. She
eventually came to despise Nixon and stayed away from the funeral."
I didn't know that Chennault came to despise Nixon, after allegedly serving him during the 1968 Presidential election.
Consequentialism for me but not for thee
23 minutes ago