Anthony C. Thiselton. Approaching the Study of Theology: An Introduction to Key Thinkers, Concepts, Methods and Debates. IVP Academic, 2018. See here to purchase the book.
Anthony C. Thiselton has taught Christian Theology at the University
of Nottingham in England. He is the author of numerous books.
As the subtitle indicates, this book is “An Introduction to Key
Thinkers, Concepts, Methods, and Debates” in the study of theology. The
book’s Introduction is entitled “Landmarks in the History of
Theology.” It covers the biblical roots of key doctrines concerning
God, humanity, and the church, as well as briefly introduces the church
fathers, the medieval era, the Reformation, and the modern period. The
section on the modern period examines both Roman Catholic and Protestant
thinkers.
Part 1 is entitled “Approaches.” The theological approaches that it
explores are biblical theology, hermeneutical theology, historical
theology, moral theology, philosophical theology, political theology,
practical theology, systematic theology, and theology of religions.
Part 2 is entitled “Concepts and Issues.” The topics that is
discusses include atonement, biblical authority, Catholicism,
Christology, ecclesiology, eschatology, feminist theology, theology of
God, humankind, justification, liturgy and liturgical theology, natural
theology, Eastern Orthodoxy, Pentecostalism, Protestantism, the
resurrection of the dead, divine revelation, sin and alienation,
theodicy, and the Trinity. Thiselton briefly mentions things that
theological thinkers have said about these topics. Some discussions
focus more on pre-modern thinkers, whereas others have a greater
emphasis on modern thinkers. Occasionally, post-modern thinkers make an
appearance. In both Parts 1 and 2, Thiselton mentions thinkers:
sometimes he offers a sentence or more about their thought, and sometime
he just lists names.
Part 3 includes key terms. I will not list all of them here. They
range from denominations (i.e., Baptists, Lutheranism), to belief
systems (i.e., atheism, agnosticism), to historical theological trends
and approaches (i.e., Thomism), to concepts in the Christian religion
(i.e., demons, predestination). This is not a brief glossary tucked in
the back of the book. It is about forty pages, and it covers a lot of
terms, providing a paragraph-length discussion of each of them.
The book ends with a bibliography, an index of Scripture and
patristic references, and index of authors, and an index of subjects.
The bibliography lists books in the fields of biblical studies (mainly
New Testament), theology, and religious denominations and trends. It
includes primary and secondary sources. There is a star system: three
stars are beside works that Thiselton recommends as textbooks, two stars
are beside works that he recommends as seminal, and one star is beside
works that he believes add special value to a given subject. Most of
the books on the list have no star at all.
In my opinion, this book would serve better as a supplementary
reference work than a beginner’s primary introductory text. Reading it
was like going on a quick tour and briefly seeing the sites. Or it was
like snacking rather than eating a full-course meal. It is difficult to
determine whether it is deep or superficial. It is easy to read this
book and say, “Is that what the great, abstruse (insert famous
theologian here) thought? I can get that from watching TBN, or by
reading popular evangelical books!” But that impression would be
off-base, for Thiselton would toss in something about the distinctness
of the theologian’s thought or approach. It just went by so fast that a
reader may forget the nuance that he or she just read. The book’s
prose was simple, but some of the discussions were a bit elliptical and
perhaps could have been fleshed out more. But one should remember that
this is not a major tome: it is a 240 page book that covers a lot of
territory, and even then there are topics that it does not cover. For a
beginner who wants to get a deeper taste of theology, Roger Olson’s
tomes (The Story of Christian Theology, The Journey of Modern Theology)
would probably be better to read. Thiselton’s book, however, would be a
suitable reference work, particularly if you want names of authors to
read in a given field or on a given topic.
Occasionally, Thiselton offers his own point-of-view. Sometimes, he
states it by inserting an adverb (i.e., “unfortunately”), without
offering much of an explanation. In some cases, he offered a viewpoint
that was intriguing and maybe outside of the box, but he did not really
ground it in historic Christian theology. For instance, he
distinguished between justification and divine forgiveness of sins, and
he questioned the Augustinian model of original sin. He appeared a few
times to be suggesting something like soul-sleep. While Thiselton is a
greater theologian than I am or will ever be, there were a few occasions
in reading this book when I took what he said with a grain of salt.
For example, he seemed to be characterizing Irenaeus as an
annihilationist. I have not done research on this particular topic, but
I am a bit skeptical about this. Saying that unbelievers will
experience a post-mortem death is not necessarily the same as being an
annihilationist, for believers in eternal torment characterize the
torment as a conscious spiritual death.
At times, this book was inspiring and edifying. The discussion of
the Cappadoccian fathers’ views on the Trinity comes to mind here.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.