Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan. Where Hope Prevails. Minneapolis: Bethany House Publishers, 2016. See here to buy the book.
Where Hope Prevails is the third book of the “Return to the
Canadian West” series. The series is about a privileged city woman,
Beth Thatcher, going to the coal mining Canadian West to teach. I read
the first two books of the series, and I have watched the first two
seasons of the Hallmark Channel TV series that is based on it, entitled When Calls the Heart. I was “meh” towards the first book, loved the second book, and absolutely adored the TV series.
In When Hope Prevails, Beth returns to the Canadian West to
teach, and she find that an additional teacher will be instructing the
older students. His name is Robert Harris Hughes. He is well-educated,
formal, and sophisticated, and he is an atheist. He has an agenda of
social engineering, as he wants to try Bertrand Russell’s educational
ideas on the rough Canadian West. Beth, a devout Christian, fears the
influence that Robert will have on his students.
The main reason I wanted to read this book was to see how this
Christian novel would portray the clash in worldviews. And the book did
that rather well. While Robert Harris Hughes in the book does put on
airs and can be rather tactless, in a sophisticated sort of way, the
book does not demonize him. Beth’s love interest Jarrick sees him as a
man pursuing wisdom. Molly, whose homespun spiritual wisdom I
appreciated in the first book, encourages Beth to love Robert. Molly is
unfazed by his atheism, realizing that the Holy Spirit can speak to his
heart. Beth and Robert even have a debate about the historicity of the
Exodus! The book ended on a rather open-ended note, in terms of
Robert’s role in the story. I hope that he is in future books, and even
in the TV series.
The book covered other territory as well. Jarrick and Beth are
engaged, and Beth’s father has offered Jarrick a job in the city. That
would mean that Beth would have to quit teaching, which she is reluctant
to do. One of Beth’s students, Marnie, has met someone, and that may
mean that Marnie will not pursue a career in teaching, which is what
Beth wants for her. There are also the usual sinister interests in the
area, pursuing power in corrupt and insidious ways. That affects the
visiting schoolteacher, Robert Harris Hughes!
The book covered a lot of territory, and I would have preferred that
it focus more on the tension in worldview between Beth and Robert.
Still, it was an enjoyable read.
I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley, in exchange for an honest review.
3 hours ago