I started Monica Crowley's Nixon Off the Record: His Candid Commentary on People and Politics.
You may have seen Monica Crowley on Fox News, MSNBC, or the McLaughlin Group. She's a conservative pundit, yet she's an educated
conservative pundit, for she has a Ph.D. in International Relations
from Columbia University. Incidentally, her sister is married to Alan
Colmes, who was the liberal on the Fox News program, Hannity and Colmes.
I
first heard of Monica Crowley when I was living in New York City, which
was from 2002 to 2004. I listened to her on the radio. To be honest,
as a listener, I didn't care for her that much. She just struck me as
so uncritically right-wing. Granted, she backed away from that somewhat
when it was becoming clear that Iraq was not using forbidden weapons on
American invaders (or liberators, if you prefer), but, overall, her
spiel seemed to me to be that Republicans are good, whereas Democrats
are bad. After John Kerry gave his speech to the Democratic National
Convention in 2004, her reaction to it, predictably, was that Kerry did a
poor job.
When I watched her on the McLaughlin Group and later
Fox News, however, I was pleasantly surprised. It wasn't because she
was attractive----I already knew she was attractive when I didn't care
for her----but rather it was because she appeared to have a
sophisticated, three-dimensional perspective on issues and political
personalities, more than seemed to be the case when I was living in New
York City, listening to her on the radio. She was still a
conservative on the McLaughlin Group and Fox News, but she was more of a
thoughtful conservative than she seemed to be on the radio (at least
when I happened to be listening to her).
I knew when I
listened to her on the radio in New York City that she had worked for
former President Richard Nixon during the 1990's. Essentially, she
wrote Nixon a long letter about foreign policy, and, to her surprise,
Nixon responded to her letter and invited her to chat with him, which
led to a job. On one of the episodes of her radio program, she was
talking about Nixon and some of her experiences working for him. Now, I
was somewhat of a Nixon fan at the time, so I can enjoy a good anecdote
about how Nixon was such a nice guy and was so often misunderstood.
But even I had a hard time stomaching that episode. It just struck me
as a one-sided whitewash, a hagiography, if you will----as if Nixon had
few if any flaws.
Years later (well, last year, to be
exact), I was planning to do my Year (or More) of Nixon on my blog for
the year 2013, which would be the centennial of Nixon's birth. I took a
look at the Amazon reviews of Monica Crowley's books on Nixon, Nixon Off the Record and Nixon in Winter. And,
from the reviews, I concluded that her books were not a hagiography,
but rather a balanced, realistic perspective on the man, a man who had
his share of sensitivity, vulnerability, grudges, and thoughtfulness,
not to mention a desire for people to value his opinion. So I bought the books. I'll be blogging through Nixon Off the Record, and, probably in a couple of months or more from now, I'll blog through Nixon in Winter.
In
my reading so far, it's basically Nixon pontificating. At first, that
was interesting to me, and yet annoying. Nixon was talking about how a
good leader needs "head, heart, and guts", and he was critiquing leaders
who had some of those qualities but not others. What annoyed me was
that he seemed to be upholding himself as the standard. Part of my
annoyance may be due to the fact that I just read two anti-Nixon books
for my Year (or More) of Nixon, and so, with the stuff from those books
in my mind, I wondered where he came off acting so high and mighty. And yet, even before I read those anti-Nixon books, back when I was reading Nixon's 1962 book Six Crises,
I found Nixon's moralizing to be rather irritating. I enjoyed his
talent as a storyteller, his acknowledgement of his flaws, and his
analysis of issues, but not so much his moralistic pontifications about
how to meet a crisis. His memoirs were not as bad in terms of
his moralizing, and Nixon appeared to be humbler in his memoirs on
account of the mistakes in judgment that he made during the Watergate
scandal. He was still pretty defensive in his memoirs, but humbler than
he was in Six Crises. And yet, ironically, I actually enjoyed reading Six Crises more than his memoirs, perhaps because he seemed friendlier in that book, or his writing was better, or other factors.
But back to Nixon Off the Record!
I started to like the book when Nixon was sharing his opinions about
certain Presidents: Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Ford,
Carter, Reagan, and Bush. Of all of these Presidents, Nixon appeared to
have the highest opinion of Truman, who (according to Nixon) went with
his gut, and often turned out to be right. This is ironic, since
Nixon's early political career was largely based on attacking the Truman
Administration, plus Truman long held a grudge against Nixon because
Nixon supposedly called him a traitor. On the other Presidents, Nixon
is largely ambivalent: he still had hurt feelings from his time as
Eisenhower's Vice-President; he did not respect Ford's post-Presidential
activities (i.e., making money off of delivering speeches and playing
golf); he didn't care for Carter and Carter's meddling in foreign policy
after leaving the Presidency, yet he grudgingly respected Carter for
building houses for the poor; he admired Reagan's leadership and
considered Reagan to be a decent fellow, yet he believed that Reagan
was naive about Gorbachev, that Reagan's domestic policies lacked
compassion, and that Reagan wasn't very professional when sleeping
during cabinet meetings (Nixon was careful in expressing his opinions
about Reagan to Monica because her ideology was highly influenced by the
Reagan Presidency); and he felt that Bush I was too nice and not tough enough.
What
Nixon said about Kennedy disappointed me somewhat, since I want to like
Kennedy, who often came across as someone who was funny and likable,
and who did not take himself too seriously. (It's like what Peter
Griffin said about Sarah Silverman on Family Guy: he wants to
like her, so he hopes she's a nice person!) According to Nixon, both
John and Bobby Kennedy were often mean and rude to the help. My
impression from things I have read and seen on TV is that Nixon tried to
be courteous to the help. In the movies Nixon and Frost vs. Nixon, his character is kind to his butler: he chats with the butler and has listened to the butler's stories. In either Six Crises
or his memoirs (I forget which), Nixon criticizes high officials in the
Soviet establishment for seeing themselves as such men of the people,
when they ignored the help, as if the help were mere furniture. There
may be more sides to Nixon than this: Whether or not Nixon was kind to
the help, Ambrose narrates that Nixon alienated his staff due to his
temper! But Nixon's humble roots may have influenced him to try to be
kind to the help.
I was somewhat intrigued by Nixon's opinions on Oliver Stone's JFK in Monica's book, not only because I love the movie, but also because Oliver Stone's Nixon
seemed to imply that Nixon suspected that the Bay of Pigs fiasco
unleashed forces (anti-Castro forces) that led to Kennedy's
assassination. Reportedly, even Nixon's aide, H.R. Haldeman, thought
that Nixon was referring to the Kennedy assassination when he (Nixon)
expressed fears that the FBI investigation into Watergate could "open up
the whole Bay of Pigs thing" (see here). But, in Monica's book, Nixon essentially says that Stone doesn't know what he's talking about in JFK,
that a lone-gunman killed Kennedy, and that (contrary to Stone's
thesis) Kennedy was actually escalating the war in Vietnam, not planning
to withdraw.
I'll close this post by quoting something profound that Monica says on page xii:
"My
four years with President Nixon were not White House years, vice
presidential years, or years in Congress. They were the last of the
post-presidency years. What Nixon had accomplished during his years in
power determined how others would judge him; what he did during his
final years out of power would determine how he ultimately saw himself."