I started Bruce Mazlish's 1972 book, In Search of Nixon: A Psychohistorical Inquiry.
The edition of the book that I have is dated to 1973, which was when
the Watergate scandal was occurring. In my edition, Mazlish has a new
introduction that touches on Watergate.
I may have heard of
Mazlish's book when I was an undergraduate. I was taking a class on
American Government, and the professor referred to a book that came out
back when Nixon was President. This book attempted to make a
psychological analysis of Nixon. According to my professor, once the
Watergate scandal broke out, people took a second look at this book, and
they began to psychologically evaluate other Presidents, as well. I'm
not sure if my professor had Mazlish's book in mind. I have another
book that I will read after Mazlish, Eli Chesen's President Nixon's Psychiatric Profile,
which is dated to 1973. But Chesen refers to Mazlish's work, so
Mazlish may very well have been one of the first to write a book that
psychologically analyzed Nixon.
How did Mazlish undertake his task
of psychologically analyzing Nixon? Did he meet with Nixon himself?
As far as I know, Mazlish did not. Essentially, Mazlish relied on
Nixon's speeches, remarks that Nixon made in public, Nixon's Six Crises,
and biographies of Nixon. Mazlish defends his method. Although there
were many times when others wrote Nixon's speeches, and there were other
hands that played a role in the composition of Six Crises,
Nixon was still involved in the process, advising, supervising,
approving, and even composing material himself. Regarding the
biographies that existed at the time, it's interesting how they
contradict each other on certain factual details, such as whether Pat
Nixon was older or younger than Richard. But Mazlish looks at details
in the biographies in his attempt to understand what Nixon is like, and
why. In my opinion, Mazlish's case is rather plausible, even though
Mazlish wrote before the release of H.R. Haldeman's diaries and the
great epic biographies of Nixon by such authors as Roger Morris, Stephen
Ambrose, and others.
I used to read pieces of Mazlish's book when
I was a student at Harvard Divinity School. I would take a study break
at the Hilles library, and during that time I would read parts of
Mazlish's book, but not the entire thing. Years later, in 2012, when I
was looking for books to read for my Year (or More) of Nixon, I was
trying to remember what book I read at Hilles, but I was drawing a
blank. I did a search online, but I could not find what I was seeking.
In the process, I stumbled upon Chesen's book, but I knew after I got
it in the mail that it was not the book that I read at Hilles. One
evening, I looked at the bibliography of Stephen Ambrose's Nixon: The Education of a Politician. I saw Mazlish's book listed, I looked it up on Amazon, and, bingo, that was the book I had read at Hilles!
The
reason that I was drawn to Mazlish's book back when I was at Harvard
was that I could identify with features of Nixon's personality, as
Mazlish described them: Nixon's tendency to be a loner, yet Nixon's
lighting up as a light-bulb whenever a crowd loved him; Nixon's
quietness; the alienation that Nixon felt from certain sophisticated
circles; Nixon's hard work; how Nixon's mannerisms when speaking looked
rather contrived; Nixon's lack of physical coordination; Nixon's love
for daydreaming; Nixon's tendency at times to act on ideas that he came
up with in solitude, without telling his aides; and Nixon's lack of
dates with women (though he did have more dates than I did). I was
intrigued by how Nixon would drive Pat on her dates with other men.
Nixon just wouldn't go away! In reading Mazlish recently, I liked
Mazlish's quote of Gary Wills, who said that Nixon tended to hang around
when he was not wanted, with the result that he was a leftover, but one
who still could find a job to do within that capacity! I'd rather be
loved, but if I could get a job as a leftover because I just keep
showing up, that's all right with me!
To give you an example of
how Mazlish traces elements of Nixon's personality to events in his
life, I'll refer to a cluster of events that Mazlish talks about. When
Nixon was living at home with his parents during his younger years, two
of his brothers died. One was Arthur, who was expected to be a girl and
was somewhat treated like a girl. The other was Harold, who was the
firstborn, and whom Nixon said was his parents' favorite. When Harold
got tuberculosis, Nixon's mother Hannah went with Harold to live in
Arizona, where the air was drier. Richard was now away from his mother,
and he lived in California with his father. Nixon heard his father's
outrage over the Teapot Dome scandal within the Harding Administration,
and it was at that point that Nixon abandoned his dream to be a railroad
engineer who would go to faraway places and see the world; rather,
Nixon would be an attorney, one who couldn't be bought!
How did
these elements of Nixon's life influence the sort of person who Nixon
became, according to Mazlish? When Arthur was sissified, Richard was
repulsed by the concept of sissies, according to Mazlish. When his Mom
was away, Nixon saw dependence on people as a weakness. That's why
Nixon was critical of "bums" (even though his Mom and grandmother fed
the tramps who came to their door) and used the word as an epithet for
anti-war protesters, whom he believed grew up with things handed to them
on a silver platter. That's why Nixon admired strength----which is
evident in his marriage to a strong woman (Pat) who pressured him to
stand up for himself and sometimes even chewed him out in public,
Nixon's admiration for Communist leaders (as much as he loathed
Communism), and his desire that America look strong in the Vietnam War.
According to Mazlish, the death of Nixon's two brothers may explain why
Nixon sees life as a series of crises to be met head on and surmounted,
and why Nixon tries to beat death. And Nixon's gravitation to his
father after his mother went to Arizona explains Nixon's entrance into
public life (which Richard's Mom did not want for Richard), and also his
love for hamburgers and spaghetti, which was a staple when Nixon's
father Frank was raising his sons (other than Harold) on his own. And
yet, there was still within Richard Nixon some of the kid who wanted to
be a railroad engineer who would see the world. That's Nixon the
daydreamer, but also the Nixon who has no home. Mazlish refers to
Theodore White's statement that, in a sense, Washington D.C. was Nixon's
only home. Nixon got to the point where he was rather alienated from
California, and Nixon long saw the eastern United States as a strange,
exotic place that excluded him (though he later worked there as a
lawyer). But Washington, D.C. was his home.