Judge Jeanine Pirro. Liars, Leakers, and Liberals: The Case Against the Anti-Trump Conspiracy. Center Street, 2018.
Judge Jeanine Pirro. Radicals, Resistance, and Revenge: The Left’s Plot to Remake America. Center Street, 2019.
Judge Jeanine Pirro has been a prosecutor, a judge, and an
Emmy-winning host of a televised court show. She is currently a Fox News
personality. Here are some thoughts and observations about her books:
A. Pirro praises Donald Trump’s accomplishments as President.
Unemployment has been at an all-time low over the past three years,
notwithstanding the Federal Reserve raising interest rates; by contrast,
economic growth during the Obama years was sluggish, even as the Fed
kept interest rates low. Pirro attributes the economic growth under
Trump to Trump’s deregulation and lowering of the corporate tax rate.
Further on the domestic front, Trump has acted on issues about which
liberals only talk, such as criminal justice reform. While Pirro admits
that she sides more with victims than criminals, she states that
criminal justice reform reduces recidivism and thus is a positive
development. On the international scale, Trump has gotten results. After
Trump threatened to impose a tariff on Mexican products, Mexico started
taking care of illegal immigrants rather than sending them in masse to
the United States. Trump has helped bring North and South Korea to the
negotiating table, even as North Korea abandons its nuclear program.
Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, has presided over historic
cooperative meetings among Israel and Arab nations, particularly Saudi
Arabia, as they seek common ground. Trump’s tough stance towards China
has gotten positive results. Some of Pirro’s analysis, particularly on
North Korea, is rather dated, as Kim Jong Un continues to taunt
President Trump and perform tests. As of my writing this, however
(December 2019), unemployment remains low; on the other hand, the
tariffs have resulted in high prices.
B. Pirro argues that Trump is a threat to the “deep state,” which
seeks to undermine him. She is rather nebulous about what the deep
state’s precise motivation is. What policies does the deep state support
that Trump opposes or threatens? They have said or implied that they
support global stability, which Trump threatens through his
irresponsible rhetoric and lack of knowledge, but are there areas in
which their policies benefit the establishment, whereas Trump’s ideas
walk away from that? In terms of motivations, Pirro highlights a variety
of factors. America’s intelligence agencies contain a lot of Clinton
appointees, so they lean towards the liberal establishment. Yet, Pirro
portrays James Comey as self-centered and opportunistic rather than
ideological, similar to J. Edgar Hoover, who threw around his power to
intimidate both Democratic and Republican Presidents. When Comey
criticized Hillary’s e-mails right before the 2016 election day, Pirro
contends, he was showing Hillary that he was a force with which to
reckon, even as he declined to accuse her of anything illegal. While
Pirro’s books are incomplete in detailing the motivations of the deep
state, she is clearer in highlighting the motivations of other opponents
of Trump: a desire to profit from cheap labor, being upset at Hillary
losing the election, etc.
C. Where does Pirro stand on the non-interventionist foreign policy
with which Trump has been associated? On the one hand, she comes across
as somewhat hawkish and bellicose. Whereas some like Trump for being
pro-Russian, Pirro denies that Trump is that, for Trump has imposed
tough sanctions on Russia and has assisted the Ukraine. She praises
Trump for bombing Assad’s Syria. She speaks rather favorably about
George W. Bush’s War on Terror. On the other hand, Pirro seems to favor a
non-interventionist foreign policy. While she supports Trump’s
strategic bombing of Syria, she agrees with Trump that regime change is
not the way to go, for who knows what will replace Assad? We saw how
Obama’s overthrow of Qadaffi in Libya turned out, as Islamic extremists
supplanted the Libyan dictator. Pirro praises Trump for speaking against
the Iraq War in a Republican debate, amidst an audience of Bush
loyalists who roundly booed him. She agrees with Trump that NATO
countries should shoulder more of the financial burden.
D. Pirro provides an effective discussion of so-called socialism in
the Scandinavian countries. Contra Bernie Sanders, Pirro argues that
Scandinavia is not exactly socialistic. It has a policy of low corporate
tax rates and few government regulations, which stimulates the economy
and allows it to pay for its generous social programs; meanwhile, it
seeks to make its social programs less generous. When Scandinavia tried
the Bernie approach, which is to soak only the rich to pay for its
social programs, the result was economic disaster, which was why it
embraced low corporate taxes and fewer government regulations. At the
same time, Pirro notes, taxes are high in Scandinavia, particularly for
the middle class. The VAT is a tax on sales that people throughout
Europe have to pay. One question Pirro does not address in this
discussion is how Scandinavia’s economy does so well, with such high tax
rates. Even if businesses produce a lot as a result of low corporate
taxes and few government regulations, would not the high individual tax
rates and the VAT discourage consumers from buying those products?
E. Pirro talks a lot about the private Trump and the private Hillary.
The private Trump, she believes she knows, for she and he have been
long-time friends. She has observed his interaction with his children as
a father, and she knows about his work ethic, his common touch, and his
generosity towards those in need. Hillary, she does not seem to know
personally, but she bases her portrayal of Hillary on things she has
experienced and learned. She almost ran against Hillary for U.S. Senate,
and Hillary spread untrue rumors against her. She knows people who live
in Hillary’s town, and, while people in town see Bill a lot, they
almost never see Hillary; Pirro interprets this as Hillary’s contempt
towards the non-elites. Pirro also refers to a speech in which Hillary
says that the more creative parts of the country voted for her in 2016
rather than Trump, which Pirro sees as Hillary’s dismissal of “flyover
country.” Speaking for myself, I do not judge Hillary for being aloof,
since I can be introverted and aloof myself. But that does make me less
likely to vote for her, since she seems to be a bit of a snob.
F. The topic of sexism occurs in Pirro’s first book. Pirro talks
about her own experience with sexism when she helped implement a policy
against domestic violence. She quotes Kellyanne Conway, who sees sexism
within the Republican Party as a problem. Pirro notes favorably that
Trump employed women in prominent positions, back when that was rare. At
the same time, Pirro is not a fan of the women’s march, which she sees
as merely anti-Trump rather than constructive. She also points out the
hypocrisy of the establishment media, which lauded Ivanka Trump as a
businesswoman, then changed its tune once her father ran for President.
G. In a number of cases, Pirro is detailed and informative in her
discussions. She brings her legal expertise into her analysis, as when
she defends Attorney General Barr against the charge that he perjured
himself. In criticizing the Steele dossier, which became the basis for
Obama’s spying on Trump’s campaign, she notes that the mainstream media
saw through it and rejected it as unreliable. While she acknowledges
that some of Trump’s appointees have ethical problems, she contends that
they are minor, compared with what most politicians do, and she
contends that Robert Mueller has tried to lessen their sentences if they
will hand over alleged dirt on Trump. Pirro is also helpful in
explaining the purpose of ICE and how it differs from the INS: ICE, in
contrast with the INS, focuses on finding the illegal immigrants who are
in the country. Where Pirro may be a bit sketchy is that she assumes as
factual the idea that Hillary Clinton gave uranium to Russia, in
exchange for contributions to the Clinton foundation and expensive
speaking fees for Bill. This claim has been widely disputed.
While the book is detailed, it is an easy read—-perhaps because of its conversational tone, clarity, and passion.
Sunday, March 29, 2020
Church Write-Up: Worldliness
This morning, I watched my church’s Wednesday and Sunday services.
Some items:
A. The Wednesday service focused on worldliness. “Worldliness” was defined as attachment to the things of the world.
The youth pastor showed the types of outfits that he used to wear to look “cool” to his peers. As a teen, he wore his hoodie backwards because a band was doing that at the time. But he learned that God already thinks he’s cool, so he does not need to look cool to others.
The pastor talked about the story of the rich young ruler. The rich young ruler thought that he oriented his life around God. At least he observed the commandments as he thought they should be done! But his possessions, with the status and reputation that they brought him, were hard for him to let go, so he rejected Jesus’s admonition that he sell all and follow him. Jesus was saddened by this, for the man was so close to entering the Kingdom of God. We, too, are possessed by things other than God, but God offers us hope. With human beings, salvation is impossible, but all things are possible for God. Jesus made salvation possible by purchasing us as his own.
B. The Sunday service focused on building on a strong foundation, the foundation of Jesus and his words. Trusting in other things, such as our wealth, may fail us, as is occurring amidst the current pandemic. When we trust in Jesus, however, we realize that this world is merely temporary and that God is taking care of us, now and in eternity. People who hoard toilet paper show that they prioritize personal comfort over love of God and neighbor. I can sympathize with them, though. God having a good afterlife in store for me does not help me right now if I am totally out of toilet paper!
Some items:
A. The Wednesday service focused on worldliness. “Worldliness” was defined as attachment to the things of the world.
The youth pastor showed the types of outfits that he used to wear to look “cool” to his peers. As a teen, he wore his hoodie backwards because a band was doing that at the time. But he learned that God already thinks he’s cool, so he does not need to look cool to others.
The pastor talked about the story of the rich young ruler. The rich young ruler thought that he oriented his life around God. At least he observed the commandments as he thought they should be done! But his possessions, with the status and reputation that they brought him, were hard for him to let go, so he rejected Jesus’s admonition that he sell all and follow him. Jesus was saddened by this, for the man was so close to entering the Kingdom of God. We, too, are possessed by things other than God, but God offers us hope. With human beings, salvation is impossible, but all things are possible for God. Jesus made salvation possible by purchasing us as his own.
B. The Sunday service focused on building on a strong foundation, the foundation of Jesus and his words. Trusting in other things, such as our wealth, may fail us, as is occurring amidst the current pandemic. When we trust in Jesus, however, we realize that this world is merely temporary and that God is taking care of us, now and in eternity. People who hoard toilet paper show that they prioritize personal comfort over love of God and neighbor. I can sympathize with them, though. God having a good afterlife in store for me does not help me right now if I am totally out of toilet paper!
Labels:
Church
Monday, March 23, 2020
Book Write-Up: Paul and the Giants of Philosophy
Joseph R. Dodson and David E. Briones, ed. Paul and the Giants of Philosophy: Reading the Gospel in Greco-Roman Context. IVP Academic, 2019. See here to purchase the book.
This book compares and contrasts the apostle Paul’s ideas with those of Stoic, Epicurean, and Peripatetic (i.e., Aristotle) philosophers. Ancient Greco-Roman philosophy was not merely an abstract intellectual exercise but addressed how people can concretely live a happy, ethical life. The book addresses topics of this nature, including suffering, therapy, friendship, communitarianism, faith, altruism and egoism, and dealing with death. But the book also covers historical, antiquarian territory: slavery, letter writing, heavenly visions, Jewish and Pauline application of pagan poetry, and the challenge of comparing Paul with pagan philosophers.
Some thoughts and observations:
A. Dorothea H. Bertschmann and Brian J. Tabb both offer contributions about the topic of suffering. Betschmann contrasts Paul with Stoicism, arguing that Stoicism stressed the character-building utility of suffering, whereas Paul regarded it as an alien intrusion into God’s good creation. Tabb, however, contends that Paul acknowledges that suffering builds character in Christians. Bertschmann, in my opinion, does well to point out that suffering does not always produce positive moral character, for it can influence people to become bitter and self-absorbed. Tabb appears to be closer, though, to what Paul thought: that suffering can produce hope and perseverance. An added note: Bertschmann’s chapter ends with a chart comparing Paul with Epictetus. Some of the chapters in this book had such a chart, whereas others did not. The charts were helpful in summarizing and condensing the information. Ironically, Bertschann’s chart seems to go in the opposite direction from what she argues in the chapter, for the chart appears to suggest that Paul acknowledged that suffering can create good character.
B. David E. Briones has a chapter entitled “Strings Attached: Paul and Seneca on the Modern Myth of the Pure Gift.” Briones argues that altruism—-the moral value of giving a gift without any hope or expectation of reciprocity—-is a modern rather than an ancient idea. Greco-Roman society stressed gratitude for favors given, and Paul agrees with that sentiment. When I saw the title, I braced myself, for I expected it to promote salvation by works and law rather than by God’s free grace. The law and works would be incorporated into salvation, of course, under the guise of “gratitude.” The chapter has some of that, but, overall, its focus is on interpersonal relationships: how egoism and reciprocity are part of Paul’s ethics, meaning Paul is not entirely pro-altruism. That makes sense to me, for I have never understood Christians who claim that we are to think of others instead of ourselves. I doubt that they follow that principle, or that it even can be thoroughly and consistently followed, for people are naturally supposed to take care of themselves. Briones’s argument that altruism is a modern rather than an ancient idea, however, seems to be a stretch. Briones cites passages in which Seneca appears to see value in giving without hope of return, and Jesus instructed his disciples to do so in the Sermons on the Mount and Plain.
C. Ben C. Dunson has a chapter entitled “All for One and One for All: Individual and Community in Paul and Epictetus.” Dunson says that, according to Paul, there is no such person as a “lone-ranger Christian.” That is impossible, as far as Paul is concerned. Christians, as a community, are to offer themselves as a living sacrifice to God. I cannot refute Dunson’s interpretation of Paul at the moment: maybe it is correct. Still, I fail to understand why it is impossible to be a lone-ranger Christian. Maybe undesirable, but impossible? Not everyone in this day and age can fit into a Christian community. Are we to say that they are non-Christians on account of that? Can they not have a personal connection to and relationship with God, even if they are alienated from Christian community? “But being in a community helps you to love,” someone may say. Fair point, but that should not relate to whether one qualifies as a Christian; salvation is by grace, not law.
D. The tendency of many modern apologists is to argue that Christianity was light-years ahead of ancient paganism, in terms of morality and the type of God that it portrayed. Atheist scholar and historian Richard Carrier, in my opinion, presents effective counterarguments to that in his book, Not the Impossible Faith. Paul and the Giants of Philosophy is not as bad as modern apologetics, for it acknowledges that pagan philosophy believed in kindness and humility, and that some pagan philosophers even held that God was kind. James P. Ware argues that Paul thought that God conquered death, whereas pagan philosophy tended to believe that the gods could not defeat death. Ware raises important considerations. As far as I can recall from Carrier’s book (and my memory may be incomplete), pagans had stories about dead people coming back to life (bodily resuscitation), but not the bodily resuscitated coming back to life as immortal beings.
E. The more historical chapters are informative. Timothy A. Brookins has a chapter on slavery, and he has a passage about how difficult being a slave was in antiquity (i.e., having to stand all day, being whipped for sneezing). E. Randolph Richards compares the letters of Paul and Seneca with letter-writing in antiquity. The letters of Paul and Seneca were longer than typical letters, and part of that is because their aim was to educate, not merely to talk about the details of everyday life.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
This book compares and contrasts the apostle Paul’s ideas with those of Stoic, Epicurean, and Peripatetic (i.e., Aristotle) philosophers. Ancient Greco-Roman philosophy was not merely an abstract intellectual exercise but addressed how people can concretely live a happy, ethical life. The book addresses topics of this nature, including suffering, therapy, friendship, communitarianism, faith, altruism and egoism, and dealing with death. But the book also covers historical, antiquarian territory: slavery, letter writing, heavenly visions, Jewish and Pauline application of pagan poetry, and the challenge of comparing Paul with pagan philosophers.
Some thoughts and observations:
A. Dorothea H. Bertschmann and Brian J. Tabb both offer contributions about the topic of suffering. Betschmann contrasts Paul with Stoicism, arguing that Stoicism stressed the character-building utility of suffering, whereas Paul regarded it as an alien intrusion into God’s good creation. Tabb, however, contends that Paul acknowledges that suffering builds character in Christians. Bertschmann, in my opinion, does well to point out that suffering does not always produce positive moral character, for it can influence people to become bitter and self-absorbed. Tabb appears to be closer, though, to what Paul thought: that suffering can produce hope and perseverance. An added note: Bertschmann’s chapter ends with a chart comparing Paul with Epictetus. Some of the chapters in this book had such a chart, whereas others did not. The charts were helpful in summarizing and condensing the information. Ironically, Bertschann’s chart seems to go in the opposite direction from what she argues in the chapter, for the chart appears to suggest that Paul acknowledged that suffering can create good character.
B. David E. Briones has a chapter entitled “Strings Attached: Paul and Seneca on the Modern Myth of the Pure Gift.” Briones argues that altruism—-the moral value of giving a gift without any hope or expectation of reciprocity—-is a modern rather than an ancient idea. Greco-Roman society stressed gratitude for favors given, and Paul agrees with that sentiment. When I saw the title, I braced myself, for I expected it to promote salvation by works and law rather than by God’s free grace. The law and works would be incorporated into salvation, of course, under the guise of “gratitude.” The chapter has some of that, but, overall, its focus is on interpersonal relationships: how egoism and reciprocity are part of Paul’s ethics, meaning Paul is not entirely pro-altruism. That makes sense to me, for I have never understood Christians who claim that we are to think of others instead of ourselves. I doubt that they follow that principle, or that it even can be thoroughly and consistently followed, for people are naturally supposed to take care of themselves. Briones’s argument that altruism is a modern rather than an ancient idea, however, seems to be a stretch. Briones cites passages in which Seneca appears to see value in giving without hope of return, and Jesus instructed his disciples to do so in the Sermons on the Mount and Plain.
C. Ben C. Dunson has a chapter entitled “All for One and One for All: Individual and Community in Paul and Epictetus.” Dunson says that, according to Paul, there is no such person as a “lone-ranger Christian.” That is impossible, as far as Paul is concerned. Christians, as a community, are to offer themselves as a living sacrifice to God. I cannot refute Dunson’s interpretation of Paul at the moment: maybe it is correct. Still, I fail to understand why it is impossible to be a lone-ranger Christian. Maybe undesirable, but impossible? Not everyone in this day and age can fit into a Christian community. Are we to say that they are non-Christians on account of that? Can they not have a personal connection to and relationship with God, even if they are alienated from Christian community? “But being in a community helps you to love,” someone may say. Fair point, but that should not relate to whether one qualifies as a Christian; salvation is by grace, not law.
D. The tendency of many modern apologists is to argue that Christianity was light-years ahead of ancient paganism, in terms of morality and the type of God that it portrayed. Atheist scholar and historian Richard Carrier, in my opinion, presents effective counterarguments to that in his book, Not the Impossible Faith. Paul and the Giants of Philosophy is not as bad as modern apologetics, for it acknowledges that pagan philosophy believed in kindness and humility, and that some pagan philosophers even held that God was kind. James P. Ware argues that Paul thought that God conquered death, whereas pagan philosophy tended to believe that the gods could not defeat death. Ware raises important considerations. As far as I can recall from Carrier’s book (and my memory may be incomplete), pagans had stories about dead people coming back to life (bodily resuscitation), but not the bodily resuscitated coming back to life as immortal beings.
E. The more historical chapters are informative. Timothy A. Brookins has a chapter on slavery, and he has a passage about how difficult being a slave was in antiquity (i.e., having to stand all day, being whipped for sneezing). E. Randolph Richards compares the letters of Paul and Seneca with letter-writing in antiquity. The letters of Paul and Seneca were longer than typical letters, and part of that is because their aim was to educate, not merely to talk about the details of everyday life.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
Sunday, March 22, 2020
Church Write-Up: Church at Home (Week 1)
Here are some items from the church services on Wednesday and Sunday. I watched them online.
A. Sunday’s church service was very well done. I felt almost as if I were there. The pastor led the liturgy and did the sermon in his usual robes. We followed along and did the responsive readings with a PDF of the church bulletin. The worship leader sang, with the words posted beside her on the screen so we could sing along. The youth pastor did an even more creative children’s message from his home. The prayers were for people I knew. I must confess, though: I was in my pajamas. I remember listening to a sermon when I was a child, and the pastor said that, if we are going to do church at home, listening to a cassette, then we should at least dress up. The youth pastor Sunday morning, by contrast, acknowledged that his audience may still be in their pajamas.
B. On Wednesday, the pastor said that we want to know. When the Governor talks about social distancing and self-isolation, we want to know for how long. The pastor told a story about when his son was a child and needed assurance as he was going to a Boy Scout camp. They passed a Methodist church, and the son assumed that his son knew the Methodist pastor because his father knew everything. I still feel that way about my Mom. I disagree with her about some issues, but I feel that, when it comes to such issues as health, she will offer me informed, practical, and reliable advice. At times, though—-probably more times than I would care to admit—-I want her news to be good. I want, not just information, but reassurance that things will be all right.
C. The pastor said that God is providing for people through their governing authorities. The youth pastor reassured the children (maybe also the adults) that God is bigger than the Corona-virus. I can see the point that God provides for people through other people: the government, doctors, people researching and seeking a cure. Maybe we can even help the process along through our prayers. But part of me struggles with the issue of God’s provision. It is one thing to feel provided for if one is a kid in his or her pajamas, enjoying time at home and relying on one’s parents for an income. But what about people who have been laid off, who feel that they cannot miss a day of work, who own a restaurant that will be closed for an unknown period of time? Plus, under the U.S. health care system, not everyone can even get tested for the virus. There are other questions: is the government’s current policy the best policy? And, conspiracy theorist will ask, is the government even benevolent through all this? I suppose we can transform our concerns into prayer, maybe even practical deeds of mercy, but one can still wonder where God is in times of uncertainty. Does God still provide in such uncertain situations, but only for those who love him or seek God’s help? I was reading and reflecting on I Kings this week. God provided for Elijah and the woman of Tyre during the famine, but there were probably many Israelites who starved and whose children died.
D. The church is continuing its way through the Red Letter Challenge, which focuses on the sayings of Jesus. The theme today was service. The pastor talked about how Jesus in John 4 persistently broke through the woman at the well’s barriers in order to make a personal connection. There was the barrier that discouraged Jewish rabbis from talking with women, as well as the issues that the woman kept raising as distractions: the question of where should one worship, for example. Jesus also went the distance on the cross. His food was to do the will of God, and the will of God was our salvation.
E. The pastor talked about a book by David Brooks that he was reading. He called Brooks a sociologist who was a Christian. I was a little surprised there. I thought Brooks was a pundit, not a sociologist, and a Jew rather than a Christian. I can find no formal academic credentials in sociology that he possesses, so the pastor may have been using the term “sociologist” loosely: Brooks is a commentator on society. As far as Brooks’s religion in concerned, that has been a topic of discussion. See here. Brooks’s second wife went to Wheaton, and people have wondered about Brooks’s current stance towards Christianity. That said, the pastor was talking about Brooks’s treatment of Genesis 1-2. Adam in Genesis 1 is assigned a task: to be a steward of creation. In Genesis 2, however, a personal dimension to Adam is acknowledged: it is not good for man to be alone. Brooks was talking about how being consumed in one’s vocation can be detrimental to other aspects of one’s humanity: one’s spirituality and need for relationships. I was unclear about how this fit into the pastor’s sermon, which was about Jesus’s vocation. Perhaps the point was that Jesus combined the vocational with the personal and relational.
A. Sunday’s church service was very well done. I felt almost as if I were there. The pastor led the liturgy and did the sermon in his usual robes. We followed along and did the responsive readings with a PDF of the church bulletin. The worship leader sang, with the words posted beside her on the screen so we could sing along. The youth pastor did an even more creative children’s message from his home. The prayers were for people I knew. I must confess, though: I was in my pajamas. I remember listening to a sermon when I was a child, and the pastor said that, if we are going to do church at home, listening to a cassette, then we should at least dress up. The youth pastor Sunday morning, by contrast, acknowledged that his audience may still be in their pajamas.
B. On Wednesday, the pastor said that we want to know. When the Governor talks about social distancing and self-isolation, we want to know for how long. The pastor told a story about when his son was a child and needed assurance as he was going to a Boy Scout camp. They passed a Methodist church, and the son assumed that his son knew the Methodist pastor because his father knew everything. I still feel that way about my Mom. I disagree with her about some issues, but I feel that, when it comes to such issues as health, she will offer me informed, practical, and reliable advice. At times, though—-probably more times than I would care to admit—-I want her news to be good. I want, not just information, but reassurance that things will be all right.
C. The pastor said that God is providing for people through their governing authorities. The youth pastor reassured the children (maybe also the adults) that God is bigger than the Corona-virus. I can see the point that God provides for people through other people: the government, doctors, people researching and seeking a cure. Maybe we can even help the process along through our prayers. But part of me struggles with the issue of God’s provision. It is one thing to feel provided for if one is a kid in his or her pajamas, enjoying time at home and relying on one’s parents for an income. But what about people who have been laid off, who feel that they cannot miss a day of work, who own a restaurant that will be closed for an unknown period of time? Plus, under the U.S. health care system, not everyone can even get tested for the virus. There are other questions: is the government’s current policy the best policy? And, conspiracy theorist will ask, is the government even benevolent through all this? I suppose we can transform our concerns into prayer, maybe even practical deeds of mercy, but one can still wonder where God is in times of uncertainty. Does God still provide in such uncertain situations, but only for those who love him or seek God’s help? I was reading and reflecting on I Kings this week. God provided for Elijah and the woman of Tyre during the famine, but there were probably many Israelites who starved and whose children died.
D. The church is continuing its way through the Red Letter Challenge, which focuses on the sayings of Jesus. The theme today was service. The pastor talked about how Jesus in John 4 persistently broke through the woman at the well’s barriers in order to make a personal connection. There was the barrier that discouraged Jewish rabbis from talking with women, as well as the issues that the woman kept raising as distractions: the question of where should one worship, for example. Jesus also went the distance on the cross. His food was to do the will of God, and the will of God was our salvation.
E. The pastor talked about a book by David Brooks that he was reading. He called Brooks a sociologist who was a Christian. I was a little surprised there. I thought Brooks was a pundit, not a sociologist, and a Jew rather than a Christian. I can find no formal academic credentials in sociology that he possesses, so the pastor may have been using the term “sociologist” loosely: Brooks is a commentator on society. As far as Brooks’s religion in concerned, that has been a topic of discussion. See here. Brooks’s second wife went to Wheaton, and people have wondered about Brooks’s current stance towards Christianity. That said, the pastor was talking about Brooks’s treatment of Genesis 1-2. Adam in Genesis 1 is assigned a task: to be a steward of creation. In Genesis 2, however, a personal dimension to Adam is acknowledged: it is not good for man to be alone. Brooks was talking about how being consumed in one’s vocation can be detrimental to other aspects of one’s humanity: one’s spirituality and need for relationships. I was unclear about how this fit into the pastor’s sermon, which was about Jesus’s vocation. Perhaps the point was that Jesus combined the vocational with the personal and relational.
Labels:
Church
Saturday, March 21, 2020
Book Write-Up: A Beginner’s Guide to New Testament Studies, by Nijay K. Gupta
Nijay K. Gupta. A Beginner’s Guide to New Testament Studies: Understanding Key Debates. Baker Academic, 2020. See here to purchase the book.
Nijay K. Gupta teaches New Testament at Portland Seminary. This book presents and assesses the spectrum of scholarly positions on key debates within New Testament studies. The topics include the synoptic problem, the historical Jesus, the historicity of the Gospel of John, a comparison between Jesus and Paul, Paul’s theological perspective, Paul’s view on the Jewish law, the Book of Revelation, pseudonymity, the stance of the New Testament towards Roman imperialism, women in leadership in the New Testament, justification by faith and judgment according to works, the interpretation of the Old Testament in the New, and the religious application and use of Scripture. Each chapter concludes with a bibliography of books that are significant in the debate.
Obviously, not every perspective is covered in this book. Christ-mythicism was absent in the chapter about the historical Jesus. But the book does cover a variety of perspectives, concisely highlighting their arguments. For some chapters, I already went into them with an overall knowledge about the debates. If the chapters did anything for me, they provided me with fuller context or names of scholars I can read to gain a further understanding of certain perspectives. In some chapters, I actually learned something new. N.T. Wright’s discussion of why he omitted consideration of the Gospel of John when he wrote Jesus and the Victory of God was noteworthy: the Gospel of John’s historicity was less believed in scholarship at that time than it is now. Also standing out to me are complementarian arguments that Junia was not an apostle (Romans 16:7), and the argument that Colossians was not written decades after Paul because Colossae was in ruins at that time, due to an earthquake. Gupta also has a fairly interesting interpretation of judgment according to works.
Some of the perspectives are irreconcilable with one another. On some, though, I agree with Gupta when he asks why it has to be either/or rather than both/and. Some say Paul believed in individual salvation, whereas others say he stressed community and the inclusion of the Gentiles. Why not both?
Gupta’s discussion of social memory stood out to me because I remember the buzz social memory created in the biblioblogosphere. Some seemed to talk as if the conventional criteria of historicity were a dead end and have been replaced by social memory. I wondered what exactly social memory contributed to the discussion. Reading Gupta, I am still not clear as to what the significance of social memory is to debates about historicity, but I appreciate that it is an intriguing dimension to pursue, perhaps as a supplement to other scholarly approaches.
I agree with what Joseph R. Dobson says on the back cover of the book: “With each chapter I read, I honestly thought, This chapter alone is worth the price of the book. The content is clear and evenhanded and is as comprehensive as possible while remaining appropriately concise. In addition to that, it’s remarkably relevant, engaging, and fun.”
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
Nijay K. Gupta teaches New Testament at Portland Seminary. This book presents and assesses the spectrum of scholarly positions on key debates within New Testament studies. The topics include the synoptic problem, the historical Jesus, the historicity of the Gospel of John, a comparison between Jesus and Paul, Paul’s theological perspective, Paul’s view on the Jewish law, the Book of Revelation, pseudonymity, the stance of the New Testament towards Roman imperialism, women in leadership in the New Testament, justification by faith and judgment according to works, the interpretation of the Old Testament in the New, and the religious application and use of Scripture. Each chapter concludes with a bibliography of books that are significant in the debate.
Obviously, not every perspective is covered in this book. Christ-mythicism was absent in the chapter about the historical Jesus. But the book does cover a variety of perspectives, concisely highlighting their arguments. For some chapters, I already went into them with an overall knowledge about the debates. If the chapters did anything for me, they provided me with fuller context or names of scholars I can read to gain a further understanding of certain perspectives. In some chapters, I actually learned something new. N.T. Wright’s discussion of why he omitted consideration of the Gospel of John when he wrote Jesus and the Victory of God was noteworthy: the Gospel of John’s historicity was less believed in scholarship at that time than it is now. Also standing out to me are complementarian arguments that Junia was not an apostle (Romans 16:7), and the argument that Colossians was not written decades after Paul because Colossae was in ruins at that time, due to an earthquake. Gupta also has a fairly interesting interpretation of judgment according to works.
Some of the perspectives are irreconcilable with one another. On some, though, I agree with Gupta when he asks why it has to be either/or rather than both/and. Some say Paul believed in individual salvation, whereas others say he stressed community and the inclusion of the Gentiles. Why not both?
Gupta’s discussion of social memory stood out to me because I remember the buzz social memory created in the biblioblogosphere. Some seemed to talk as if the conventional criteria of historicity were a dead end and have been replaced by social memory. I wondered what exactly social memory contributed to the discussion. Reading Gupta, I am still not clear as to what the significance of social memory is to debates about historicity, but I appreciate that it is an intriguing dimension to pursue, perhaps as a supplement to other scholarly approaches.
I agree with what Joseph R. Dobson says on the back cover of the book: “With each chapter I read, I honestly thought, This chapter alone is worth the price of the book. The content is clear and evenhanded and is as comprehensive as possible while remaining appropriately concise. In addition to that, it’s remarkably relevant, engaging, and fun.”
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
Monday, March 16, 2020
Book Write-Up: The God Who Trusts, by Wm. Curtis Holtzen
Wm. Curtis Holtzen. The God Who Trusts: A Relational Theology of Divine Faith, Hope, and Love. IVP Academic, 2019. See here to purchase the book.
Wm. Curtis Holtzen teaches philosophy and theology at Hope International University.
To quote the back cover of the book (and, yes, I read the whole book): “The Bible resounds with affirmations of the faithfulness and trustworthiness of God. But might God also exhibit faith and trust?”
Holtzen argues in the affirmative, making a biblical and a theological case. Throughout the Bible, God entrusts things to human beings, particularly things pertaining to stewardship, dominion, and mission. But Holtzen also seems to define faith as hope: God hopes that his loving overtures towards human beings will persuade them to love him back and to behave righteously, even though he is not sure that they will. The plethora of “perhaps” passages in Scripture, in which God states that “perhaps” something would happen, confirms Holtzen in this thesis. Holtzen also appeals to I Corinthians 13, in which love is said to believe and to hope all things. Since God is the embodiment of love, would that not mean that God believes and hopes? And Holtzen looks not only at the hope and faith of God transcendent, but also that of God incarnate: Jesus Christ, who, on earth, trusted his Father even amidst trials.
Although Holtzen is more of a philosopher and a theologian than a biblical exegete, and that is evident in the emphases of this book, it is his biblical case that undergirds his theological case. Holtzen essentially argues for open theism: that God does not know the future. This contrasts with the view that God absolutely and with certainty foreordains or foresees what people will do. After God in Genesis 22 tests Abraham and proclaims that “now I know” that Abraham fears God because he was willing to sacrifice his beloved son, Holtzen takes that literally: God, prior to Abraham passing the test, did not know that Abraham would prove faithful. For Holtzen, the hope that God expresses throughout Scripture makes sense when it is interpreted as real and as literal, rather than as accommodationist language about a static God who absolutely foreordains or knows everything that will happen. God’s love is a charade and a ruse if humans lack authentic free will, and if God has absolute knowledge about everything they will do.
The “charade” argument is a significant part of Holtzen’s presentation, but Holtzen occasionally engages arguments to the contrary. One argument to the contrary is that humans are depraved, so God has no illusions that they will do the right thing; that is why God has to take the initiative and regenerate them. Holtzen appears to acknowledge the importance of humans being born again, but he downplays human depravity. If humans were that depraved, he argues, then how would society hold together? His view may be that humans, even apart from regeneration, are able to respond to God’s loving overtures, on some level, but regeneration is needed to carry them further.
The gaping hole in this book is that, overall, Holtzen fails to engage adequately the biblical passages that run contrary to his position: passages about human depravity, divine foreknowledge, divine providence, and God causing people to do things. Indeed, Oltzen’s view that such concepts make God’s loving overtures and expressed hope a mere ruse is understandable. Still, Christians who embrace such concepts do so, not simply on the basis of the influence of Greek philosophy, but also because they believe they are taught in Scripture.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
Wm. Curtis Holtzen teaches philosophy and theology at Hope International University.
To quote the back cover of the book (and, yes, I read the whole book): “The Bible resounds with affirmations of the faithfulness and trustworthiness of God. But might God also exhibit faith and trust?”
Holtzen argues in the affirmative, making a biblical and a theological case. Throughout the Bible, God entrusts things to human beings, particularly things pertaining to stewardship, dominion, and mission. But Holtzen also seems to define faith as hope: God hopes that his loving overtures towards human beings will persuade them to love him back and to behave righteously, even though he is not sure that they will. The plethora of “perhaps” passages in Scripture, in which God states that “perhaps” something would happen, confirms Holtzen in this thesis. Holtzen also appeals to I Corinthians 13, in which love is said to believe and to hope all things. Since God is the embodiment of love, would that not mean that God believes and hopes? And Holtzen looks not only at the hope and faith of God transcendent, but also that of God incarnate: Jesus Christ, who, on earth, trusted his Father even amidst trials.
Although Holtzen is more of a philosopher and a theologian than a biblical exegete, and that is evident in the emphases of this book, it is his biblical case that undergirds his theological case. Holtzen essentially argues for open theism: that God does not know the future. This contrasts with the view that God absolutely and with certainty foreordains or foresees what people will do. After God in Genesis 22 tests Abraham and proclaims that “now I know” that Abraham fears God because he was willing to sacrifice his beloved son, Holtzen takes that literally: God, prior to Abraham passing the test, did not know that Abraham would prove faithful. For Holtzen, the hope that God expresses throughout Scripture makes sense when it is interpreted as real and as literal, rather than as accommodationist language about a static God who absolutely foreordains or knows everything that will happen. God’s love is a charade and a ruse if humans lack authentic free will, and if God has absolute knowledge about everything they will do.
The “charade” argument is a significant part of Holtzen’s presentation, but Holtzen occasionally engages arguments to the contrary. One argument to the contrary is that humans are depraved, so God has no illusions that they will do the right thing; that is why God has to take the initiative and regenerate them. Holtzen appears to acknowledge the importance of humans being born again, but he downplays human depravity. If humans were that depraved, he argues, then how would society hold together? His view may be that humans, even apart from regeneration, are able to respond to God’s loving overtures, on some level, but regeneration is needed to carry them further.
The gaping hole in this book is that, overall, Holtzen fails to engage adequately the biblical passages that run contrary to his position: passages about human depravity, divine foreknowledge, divine providence, and God causing people to do things. Indeed, Oltzen’s view that such concepts make God’s loving overtures and expressed hope a mere ruse is understandable. Still, Christians who embrace such concepts do so, not simply on the basis of the influence of Greek philosophy, but also because they believe they are taught in Scripture.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. My review is honest.
Sunday, March 15, 2020
Church Write-Up: Forgiveness (Red Letter Challenge)
I am writing my post about church a little earlier today than usual.
The reason is that I will be going to work this afternoon, so I will not
be writing the post after my traditional, epic Sunday nap.
The topic today was forgiveness. We are going through the Red Letter Challenge, and that is the topic for today.
Here are some points that were made, followed by my personal reactions.
A. The pastor said that people like to blame others and to rationalize their own sins. They may say that they have a bad habit and have had it for years, so they cannot do anything about it.
B. Jesus in John 7:53-8:11 told the woman caught in adultery, after he refused to condemn her, to go and sin no more. Was it possible for her to obey that command? Of course she sinned after that, as do all of us! The pastor said that Jesus meant that she should not allow herself to become enslaved to sin: that she should not serve sin as her master.
C. Zack Zehnder said in the Sunday school video that ninety percent of people questioned in a poll said that it was harder for them to forgive themselves than to forgive others. Someone in class remarked that, with others, we can simply forget about the sin and move on. We can still be friendly to the person. With ourselves, though, we live with our guilt and our feeling that we do not deserve to be forgiven.
D. Part of the Lord’s Prayer is “Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us.” Does that mean that God forgives us in the exact manner that we forgive others? The teacher said, “I hope not, for my own sake!” Someone in class differentiated between how God forgives and how people forgive. God can forget the sins, whereas people remember them.
E. Someone in class read from her study Bible that one who refuses to forgive others turns away from God’s forgiveness. What I heard her to be saying was that, when I say that someone else does not deserve forgiveness from God, I am indicting myself, since I, too, do not deserve forgiveness. Better to say that both of us are forgiven! What her note seemed to be suggesting, though, is that people who refuse to forgive are resisting God’s empowering of them to forgive others.
F. Jesus in Luke 19:1-10 greeted and offered to fellowship with the hated tax collector Zacchaeus. Then Zacchaeus repented by offering to repay those whom he defrauded and to give to the poor. People said that forgiveness is what led to repentance, not vice versa. Maybe, but it is noteworthy that Jesus pronounced salvation to come to Zacchaeus’s house after Zacchaeus repented. Another point that was made in class was that God’s presence in Zacchaeus’s life would influence him to make changes.
G. The pastor’s wife works with the hearing-impaired, and she shared the sign for forgiveness. It is essentially sweeping one’s hands: getting rid of the transgression, such that it is no longer there.
H. Zack Zehnder defines forgiveness as “to let go of something and give it to God because you believe He will enact justice better than you could.” Sounds rather punitive.
I. People in class talked about whether they could forgive a murderer. Someone then said that it would not be his place, since he was not a victim of the murderer.
J. The class talked about Simon Wiesenthal, a Nazi hunter who forgave a Nazi who sought forgiveness on his deathbed. Twenty-eight authors said forgiveness, in that case, was impossible. Sixteen said it was. Nine replied that they were unsure. A pastor in class said that the Nazi needed to hear those words of grace and forgiveness. The proper option would be to take the issue to the cross, but Wiesenthal likely did not have that resource, as a non-Christian.
Now for some of my personal reflections:
A. I stumble over the whole issue of forgiveness. During the “confession” part of the service, I do not know what to confess. I realize that I am flawed, but I feel that I cannot help that, and I do not intend to put myself on a perfectionist treadmill on any given week. And, yes, I do have resentment towards others. I can tell myself that I am wrong on that and why I am wrong on that, but the resentment will still be there. What I especially resent is the whole Christian implication that we should all be buddy-buddy. I am not strong enough for that.
B. I think that Jesus’s statement that God will not forgive us if we do not forgive others is a cruel passage of Scripture (or passages, since the statement appears more than once). My resentments are petty, but there are plenty of people who have been wronged much worse. To expect them to just move on from that, and to condition God’s forgiveness of them on that, is just cruel. God has a greater ability to forgive than people do, so it is not as if God and people are in the same boat and should be treated as such: in short, I think God should forgive us, even if we fail to forgive others. “But Christians have God living inside of them, and that gives them the power to forgive.” But I don’t feel anything like that. And I notice that other Christians get hurt feelings, too, and may not move on from them. “But they are not real Christians,” I can hear Christians say. Congratulations—-now I hate you, too!
C. Some define forgiveness as not seeking revenge. An atheist relative of mine responded, “But how can you get revenge?” Seriously, it is not as if I will kill anyone who makes me mad. That is against the law. Does that mean I am forgiving them? If that is the case, then lots of people, Christian and non-Christians, are forgiving people, and the bar for forgiveness is rather low. I remember Tim Keller defining forgiveness as, in part, not savaging people’s reputations behind their backs. That is probably part of it. I still wonder if that falls short of what forgiveness is, in some manner.
D. I am thankful for the times when people have forgiven me. I have said hurtful things, and I am glad that they, at least outwardly, moved on from that and treat me with respect and kindness. Here, though, I am sincerely sorry: it is not guilt that the church tries to manufacture in me through some cliches (“You have offended God far more than others have offended you.”) But I think: what would I do without such forgiveness? In some cases, I really do not give a rat’s ass if someone forgives me. If I tell off some snot and apologize for it, and he does not forgive me, oh well! In some cases, I do care, and I would feel lost if that person would not forgive me. But what if the person chose not to do so?
On that confusing note, my post ends.
The topic today was forgiveness. We are going through the Red Letter Challenge, and that is the topic for today.
Here are some points that were made, followed by my personal reactions.
A. The pastor said that people like to blame others and to rationalize their own sins. They may say that they have a bad habit and have had it for years, so they cannot do anything about it.
B. Jesus in John 7:53-8:11 told the woman caught in adultery, after he refused to condemn her, to go and sin no more. Was it possible for her to obey that command? Of course she sinned after that, as do all of us! The pastor said that Jesus meant that she should not allow herself to become enslaved to sin: that she should not serve sin as her master.
C. Zack Zehnder said in the Sunday school video that ninety percent of people questioned in a poll said that it was harder for them to forgive themselves than to forgive others. Someone in class remarked that, with others, we can simply forget about the sin and move on. We can still be friendly to the person. With ourselves, though, we live with our guilt and our feeling that we do not deserve to be forgiven.
D. Part of the Lord’s Prayer is “Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us.” Does that mean that God forgives us in the exact manner that we forgive others? The teacher said, “I hope not, for my own sake!” Someone in class differentiated between how God forgives and how people forgive. God can forget the sins, whereas people remember them.
E. Someone in class read from her study Bible that one who refuses to forgive others turns away from God’s forgiveness. What I heard her to be saying was that, when I say that someone else does not deserve forgiveness from God, I am indicting myself, since I, too, do not deserve forgiveness. Better to say that both of us are forgiven! What her note seemed to be suggesting, though, is that people who refuse to forgive are resisting God’s empowering of them to forgive others.
F. Jesus in Luke 19:1-10 greeted and offered to fellowship with the hated tax collector Zacchaeus. Then Zacchaeus repented by offering to repay those whom he defrauded and to give to the poor. People said that forgiveness is what led to repentance, not vice versa. Maybe, but it is noteworthy that Jesus pronounced salvation to come to Zacchaeus’s house after Zacchaeus repented. Another point that was made in class was that God’s presence in Zacchaeus’s life would influence him to make changes.
G. The pastor’s wife works with the hearing-impaired, and she shared the sign for forgiveness. It is essentially sweeping one’s hands: getting rid of the transgression, such that it is no longer there.
H. Zack Zehnder defines forgiveness as “to let go of something and give it to God because you believe He will enact justice better than you could.” Sounds rather punitive.
I. People in class talked about whether they could forgive a murderer. Someone then said that it would not be his place, since he was not a victim of the murderer.
J. The class talked about Simon Wiesenthal, a Nazi hunter who forgave a Nazi who sought forgiveness on his deathbed. Twenty-eight authors said forgiveness, in that case, was impossible. Sixteen said it was. Nine replied that they were unsure. A pastor in class said that the Nazi needed to hear those words of grace and forgiveness. The proper option would be to take the issue to the cross, but Wiesenthal likely did not have that resource, as a non-Christian.
Now for some of my personal reflections:
A. I stumble over the whole issue of forgiveness. During the “confession” part of the service, I do not know what to confess. I realize that I am flawed, but I feel that I cannot help that, and I do not intend to put myself on a perfectionist treadmill on any given week. And, yes, I do have resentment towards others. I can tell myself that I am wrong on that and why I am wrong on that, but the resentment will still be there. What I especially resent is the whole Christian implication that we should all be buddy-buddy. I am not strong enough for that.
B. I think that Jesus’s statement that God will not forgive us if we do not forgive others is a cruel passage of Scripture (or passages, since the statement appears more than once). My resentments are petty, but there are plenty of people who have been wronged much worse. To expect them to just move on from that, and to condition God’s forgiveness of them on that, is just cruel. God has a greater ability to forgive than people do, so it is not as if God and people are in the same boat and should be treated as such: in short, I think God should forgive us, even if we fail to forgive others. “But Christians have God living inside of them, and that gives them the power to forgive.” But I don’t feel anything like that. And I notice that other Christians get hurt feelings, too, and may not move on from them. “But they are not real Christians,” I can hear Christians say. Congratulations—-now I hate you, too!
C. Some define forgiveness as not seeking revenge. An atheist relative of mine responded, “But how can you get revenge?” Seriously, it is not as if I will kill anyone who makes me mad. That is against the law. Does that mean I am forgiving them? If that is the case, then lots of people, Christian and non-Christians, are forgiving people, and the bar for forgiveness is rather low. I remember Tim Keller defining forgiveness as, in part, not savaging people’s reputations behind their backs. That is probably part of it. I still wonder if that falls short of what forgiveness is, in some manner.
D. I am thankful for the times when people have forgiven me. I have said hurtful things, and I am glad that they, at least outwardly, moved on from that and treat me with respect and kindness. Here, though, I am sincerely sorry: it is not guilt that the church tries to manufacture in me through some cliches (“You have offended God far more than others have offended you.”) But I think: what would I do without such forgiveness? In some cases, I really do not give a rat’s ass if someone forgives me. If I tell off some snot and apologize for it, and he does not forgive me, oh well! In some cases, I do care, and I would feel lost if that person would not forgive me. But what if the person chose not to do so?
On that confusing note, my post ends.
Labels:
Church
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)